Robert is like a smaller faster version of the Mountain. At present his current gear is Widow Wail and his best feats are from his prime times in the books. added by vici-mercedes. Here are the nominees for debate moderator. Btw, I was starting to do one each day, but it seems like I don't have to do that anymore. It's just business. But I think Oberyn would be able to take Prime Robert Baratheon with how well he was handling the Mountain until he starting being stupid. My god this is one of the most even fights ever. In the event a user has nominated him/herself for multiple positions, they will win the option with the most votes. This really is a tough and great. At the same time, Jaime and Sandor are locked tight, their engagement flawless. Any other comments will be removed automatically without notice! I think ultimately it comes down to how you feel about the stylistic matchup between Robert and Oberyn. Nicknamed Barristan the Bold, he was considered by many to be one of the best swordsmen and most honorable men in all the Seven Kingdoms. Behind him, standing erect, was Ser Meryn Trant. Robert Baratheon has multiple flaws, at least one of them fatal, and Ser Barristan will exploit them all. Nov/2022: Rosa fell Umfangreicher Produkttest Beliebteste Rosa fell Bester Preis Vergleichssieger Direkt. Unsere Bestenliste Nov/2022 Umfangreicher Test Ausgezeichnete Produkte Bester Preis Testsieger JETZT vergleichen. It is damning. The bracket will be announced tomorrow afternoon. There will be only one champion selected to argue on behalf of each warrior, so two champions total. It's still not terribly wide to begin with though. Duel to death in a sinking ship with a sea dragon and a kraken fighting in the background. Waiting for him there is Barristan Selmy fully aware of Robert's cold blooded murder of the children. Nominate me once again, and I will not fail. Archaeologist believe that it comes from the late fourth century, many wonder if this might be perhaps the missing tombs of Lord Renly Baratheon and his wife, Celia Hightower. All the more reason, then, Ser Barristan's champion will have to exploit every possible weakness in Lord Robert to prevail in this final debate. In the muddy banks of the Ruby Ford, after the Usurper Robert Baratheon has killed the crown prince Rhagear, he turns his horse towards the last standing Targaryen loyalist, Barristan Selmy, who has cut down hundreds of men himself. @cdiddyman911: Oooh that's tough. Both had inklings at being good leader-types in battle. Barristan and Oberyn all lies on if Robert or Jaime can kill Oberyn in time to save their partner. George was in my town so of course I had to say hello (NO [Spoilers Extended] Not sure if this has been mentioned [Spoilers Extended] I appreciate how George uses archers (Spoilers Extended) I really hope House of the Dragon (Spoilers Main) The show is not pro-black or pro-green ( spoiler extended ) Westeros and Essos satellite style [Spoilers Main] Prominent sigils shown in House of the (No Spoilers) New Interview With GRRM Confirms HBO Passed (spoilers main) Why doesnt Tywin take another wife and [spoilers main] how good of a fighter was Ned Stark? Barristan is a member of House Selmy, a minor house of the Stormlands, that serves House Baratheon of Storm's End. I'd say team 2, but with difficulty lol. Ser Barristan Selmy took his seat at the Small Council. A throne adorned by antlers stood on the dais. Unsere Bestenliste Nov/2022 Detaillierter Test Die besten Batterien tiptoi Beste Angebote Preis-Leistungs-Sieger. Please reply here to nominate yourself to be the champion debating on behalf of Robert Baratheon, during Roberts Rebellion. A fresh sea breeze competes with the remnants of last night's burnt bowl of brown. That being said, the young Robert of the rebellion was a beast. Robert is first to charge through, and Barristan meets his offer. His skill was so legendary, he was knighted at the age of 16 by King Aegon V after competing in a King's Landing tournament as a mystery knight, defeating the Lord Commander of the Kingsguard at. Here are the nominees for Roberts champion. The idea is that the warrior will be transported to the scene. Maybe the OP can help me out, am I interpreting the rules incorrectly. Selmy and Oberyn have great finesse aspects to their fighting styles, and I think they outclass Robert in that regard, and Selmy outclasses Jaime at swordsmanship. Held his own briefly against the Smiling Knight as a teenager. @cregan_stark: Since when does Prime Jaime get Widow's Wail? The only people allowed to post in here are the two champions and the debate moderator. Here are the nominees for Barristans champion. Barristan beating Jaime 9/10 Barristan beating both Jaime and Robert 0/10, The less discussed and least likely pairing would be the Lion of Lannister Vs. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. (i.e. People can accompany their nomination by a short "sales pitch" (200 word maximum), describing why someone should vote for you or your proposed setting. Team 1, Oberyn is too much of a weak link. Ugh, I keep going back and forth, leaning towards team 2, Without reading books my gut feeling is Oberyn and Selmy. La misin fracas, y Steffon, acompaado por su esposa, volvieron a casa. Photo of Barristan Selmy for fans of House Baratheon 30082550. Ser Barristan Selmy, called Barristan the Bold, is a knight from House Selmy and the Lord Commander of the Kingsguard of Robert I Baratheon. In the street, out side a pot shop in Flea Bottom. Sneaker high schwarz - Whlen Sie dem Favoriten Unsere Bestenliste Nov/2022 - Umfangreicher Produktratgeber Die besten Favoriten Aktuelle Angebote Testsieger JETZT direkt weiterlesen! They were Seven, against Three. The reason Robert killed Rhaegar is he landed 1 hit to the chest that did enough damage to go through all of the Targaryen's armour and kill him. welches bedeutet auch, dass wir die erste Garde der jeweiligen Test- oder Vergleichsparameter stets hinterfragen und sehr wenige Datenpunkte nur dann in die . When the commander of an army goes down then the battle is over. Why would he exert that much energy against a light weapon that he knowns is being wielded by one of the greatest Westerosi swordsmen. CONTEXT Robert Baratheon Let's first take a look at Robert. Selmey beats Jamie - no doubt, but it could take some time. 4 Oberyn Martell. added by vici-mercedes. Stannis and Melisandre. One of the closest battle threads I've seen. Its very possible that Oberyn would have made a name for himself in the top couple of fighters ever had he not been stupid, but thats still a question mark. Robert in his youth slayed Prince Rhaegar himself who is on par with the Viper. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. He served as a member of the Kingsguard to Kings Jaehaerys II and Aerys II Targaryen. It could be simple. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, Comments are in random ordering and vote scores are hidden. It can be believed that Robert being the fighter he was would of commanded the va. Jump to content. It was released on March 15, 2016 in Game of Thrones: The Complete Fifth Season. The hypothetical is pretty unlikely in my opinion. Though a great swordsman looked up to his betters which means See Barriston the greatest sword other then perhaps The sword of the morning Sir Arthur Dayne himself. Prime Barristan and Prime Jaime are probably pretty equal. Please find them there. Now it's one on one. But if you want to put it all down to numbers, Team 1 has the superior amount and thus the greater chance of getting the win. The Red Viper would have a harder time with Robert then he did the mountain. Though Robert is a sheer mass of brute force, Barristan is the most acclaimed fighter in all of Westeros. Barristan Selmy details how Robert's Rebellion was a pivotal war for House . And if either Lion or Stag could put down Ser Barristan Selmy, than that would guarantee their teams victory. The moderator needs be knowledgeable about the topic being debated so they can select good questions and direct the conversation appropriately. If Jaime takes Oberyn then I think his team should win more often than not because he should defeat Oberyn fast than Barristan defeats Robert and then go for the 2v1. He only got it after Joffrey's death. In 299 AC, Celia Hightower is a young woman of dreams and hopes for her marriage to the handsome lord of Tempest Grove, Renly Baratheon. Almost too fair for a definitive victory. Killing Rhaegar at the Battle of . Barristan Selmy vs. Robert Baratheon The Latest News Discussing Episode 9, "The Green Council" Folio Society Releases A Dance with Dragons Illustrated Edition Two Weeks Until The Rise of the Dragon Discussing Episode 8, "The Lord of the Tides" The Catspaw Dagger at the Game of Thrones Studio Tour Notable Releases Durante un torneo en Bastin de Tormentas, Robert fue derrotado por Ser Barristan Selmy. : If I nominated myself for moderator and debater for person A and I won 100 votes for moderator but 200 votes to be the debater, Id win the debater vote.). The champions need to be very well versed about their respective characters. IF it is one of the fights during Roberts rebellion, would barri be his younger self. The Pardon of Barristan Selmy by King Robert Baratheon After the Battle of the Trident, Robert Baratheon, Eddard Stark and others had a decision on their hands. You are definitely in the minority there. Press J to jump to the feed. Jaime beats Oberyn before Barristan can overcome Robert in a Barristan vs Robert/Jaime vs Oberyn matchup. At present his current gear is Widow Wail and his best feats are from his prime times in the books. King Robert Baratheon was sitting at the head of it. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. His . The moderator sets the pace of the debate and chooses which questions will be asked. When the King briefly glared at him, Ser Barristan couldn't help but shrink away. Robert Baratheon had taken the Iron Throne from his family, while Aegon was currently sitting on the seat of House Baratheon. Things like inside Drogos funeral pyre arent valid options and wont be counted. Really don't know about Oberyn and Robert. Honestly I feel like a prime Robert might be able to take Jaime Lannister, the guy was a freaking monster. House Baratheon Club Join New Post. I don't think that Barristan or Robert could kill each other in time without the interruption of Jaime to tip the scale. If Jaime fights Barristan then things get a lot more interesting. In the Great Hall, Robert smiles at the dead bodies of Rhaegar's children and Ser Barristan can't control his anger. Through all my GoT posts, it probably looks like I'm a huge Jaime Lannister fanboy. Good on you. Jaime could cut off the spear very similar to how the Mountain did and he wouldn't be brutish and uncaring with his strikes. Aegon decisively headed towards it and sat upon the kingly seat. Ser Barristan will see it. On a side note, I'm happy my prediction came true. Who wins? 5 Jorah Mormont. To view the debate in its proper format click "Sort by: old". Although these sometimes give some contradictory information. Unsere Bestenliste Nov/2022 - Detaillierter Ratgeber TOP Produkte Aktuelle Schnppchen Vergleichssieger Direkt ansehen. Arthur Dayne slew Ned, and only Lord Ryswell survived, heavily wounded and unable to fight. Check back then to see who will be debating! Not to get off topic but out of everyone in. Won his first Tourney Melee at 13 Is able to kill four members of Robb's personal guard before he is captured. I'd say this match up is closer to even because it's hardness to call. 02 Nov 2022 19:56:06 Unsere Bestenliste Nov/2022 Detaillierter Test Beliebteste Wonderclean Aktuelle Angebote Alle Preis-Leistungs-Sieger Direkt lesen! The moderator needs to be impartial during the debate while also making sure the debaters stay on topic and follow the rules. Fury was building in him, Barristan could tell that much. The strength difference is negated by his use of the warhammer though he might have trouble punishing Oberyn's offensive since the likelihood of Oberyn losing his spear is lowered by Robert's use of a warhammer over a sword. No argument could be made against Robert's skill in battle. It is the eighty-third featurette of the series overall. If Cersei/Jaime demanded a trial-by-combat Robert would have faced Jaime, not some Kingsguard. This is a link to an external poll. Robert is a beast but Oberyn is very fast and deadly. Robert kills the Targaryen children himself, and before Ned can react, heads to ToJ to find his lost love. Robert Baratheon, Jaime Lannister y Ser Barristan Selmy hablan sobre historias de guerra y el Rey LocoJuego de Tronos Temporada 1 Capitulo 3Todo el contenido. In late 283 AC, Robert was crowned king.He chose his second father, Lord Jon Arryn, as his Hand of the King. Selmy beats Jaime and Robert beats Oberyn. It is feats and gear from the show and the books. War stories between Robert Baratheon, Jamie Lannister & Barristan Selmy #gameofthrones #shorts Two free book downloads plus a 30 day subscription for $0 (Audible trial), House of the Dragon S1: Episode 10 Review, House of the Dragon S1: Episode 10 Preview, A Hymn for Spring (Tower of the Hand, includes an essay on Harrenhal by us! Please remember that all tournament posts are Spoilers All! The Tower of Joy, Lyanna's screams coming from above the tower, and only Ser Selmy left. I don't doubt that Barristan could kill either 9/10 but his teammate has to survive for Barristan to stand a chance otherwise it's a 2 Vs. 1 situation where Selmy has no chance of winning. Answer (1 of 38): "King" Robert was fat and nearly useless, but even then he managed to kill a huge boar after being fatally gored by it. When comparing the best fighters in A Song of Ice and Fire, Barristan Selmy outranks Robert Baratheon. I guess I'll go for Selmy. The setting of the fight to be debated will be chosen by popular vote. Jaime and Robert Vs. Barristan and Oberyn all lies on if Robert or Jaime can kill Oberyn in time to save their partner. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. That is exactly the type of battle I try to make :D. Tough fight, If team 2 can finish the fight quickly they could win but if they take to long team 1 can break through Martell's weapon and end him which will allow them to double team Barristan giving team 1 the edge. A cool idea could be Jaime wielding Dawn while Arthur Dayne uses a basic Longsword. Unsere Bestenliste Nov/2022 Detaillierter Test Beliebteste Biggest cities in africa Bester Preis Alle Testsieger Dire. Tief verletzt durch diesen Verrat verbannt sie Mormont, der ihr seine Liebe . "Robert's Rebellion: Barristan Selmy" is the eighth featurette of the fifth season of Histories & Lore. Robert would roar, pausing the fight in the middle, as Barristan and Brienne would separate off. Jaime is younger, faster, more skilled. Please remember that all tournament posts are Spoilers All! Robert winning 8-9/10, Regarding Jaime V. Barristan, this could go either way as well. weibliche Person zeigt dir, wie sich die Kosten fr deinen Lieblingsartikel in den vergangenen tagen, Wochen und Monaten entwickelt haben und wie viel du der Zeit beim Kauf sparst. It can be a few words or up to 50. Even at a young age maturity seems apparent, and Robert can be a bit hyper. Honestly both sides are pretty even, with Oberyn being the only "weak link" (not by much tho). That 1 hit could also kill Selmy, Jaime, or Oberyn but he has to land the warhammer to do damage and if his opponent can avoid the blow, than they have a fair chance of winning. I think we all envision Oberyn dancing around and using style to his advantage, like he did with the mountain. To submit a question for the Floor Debate, send a PM to debate moderator Jen_Snow . King Robert I Baratheon was the seventeenth ruler of the Seven Kingdoms and the first king of the Baratheon dynasty. The most likely and most discussed matchup is Big Bob Vs. Pokey Stick and Incest Boy Vs. Barristan becomes a POV character in A Dance with Dragons. I think we all have the same struggle here. abgekoppelt von denen, welche der oben genannten Methoden bei der Erstellung einer Produktkategorie wie Crime cap zum Einsatz kommt, stellen wir in jedem Materie belastbar, nur objektive Kriterien fr unsere Bewertungen zu verwenden. Not really. Mods reserve final say on whether a setting is workable or not. I don't think Jaime could do the same. Ridiculous ones were discarded. My money is on Robert but an argument could be made for Oberyn dancing around the war hammer long enough to poison Robert. Please reply here to nominate a scene or setting for this debate. In the throne room, as Tywin places the babies in front of Robert. He is beyond proficient and would defeat Robert. A letter was crushed in his fist. Barristan "the Bold" Selmy recounts how he was named to the Kingsguard, saw King Aerys descend into madness but revered Prince Rhaegar Targaryen. But gun pointed at your head, you have to choose your gut choice. Team 2 should win. He was named Lord Commander under King Robert I Baratheon. [16] That said the poison on his spear would eventually get him a win but not before a long hard battle. Against Jaime, heabsolutely cannot. Robert's war hammer is an immensely cumbersome weapon that would wear him down with time, and Ser Barristan is capable of dodging his blows. You can include a short sales pitch if you'd like. @the_red_viper: @cdiddyman911: If that's the case then the gap between Jaime and Barristan gets a little wider. Jaime having a Valyiran steel sword inches him ever so much closer to Barristan and possibly puts them as equals. Dieser tritt in ihre Dienste und berichtet ihr, dass Jorah Mormont fr Robert spioniert hat. And Robert has a weak point. He would be quick and accurate which would end the Red Viper. I think most people would agree Robert is the better warrior (not by a lot mind you), but Oberyn might have the right style to win. (Spoilers Main) Who is this Celtigar woman missing an eye? Check back Friday to see who won and will be granted the winning flair! Worauf Sie als Kunde beim Kauf der Gefrierbox 12v 230v Aufmerksamkeit richten sollten Unsere Bestenliste Nov/2022 Detaillierter Produkttest Die besten Geheimtipps Aktuelle Angebote Smtliche Vergleichssieger Jetzt vergleichen. I'd back team 2 in an extremely difficult decision to make, Oberyn's spear should give him an edge against Robert and he should be skilled enough to avoid his spear from being broken or at the least for the most of the fight. Next thread I will have to make sure to specify. Let's see how people talk about Robert Baratheon from the old days (paraphrased from the book. It was a large hall, albeit sparsely decorated, mayhap due to the lack of use in the past twenty years. So this fight depends on the match up for me. Add Jaime if you cant see the trio winning and Dawn for Dayne. Unsere Bestenliste Nov/2022 Ultimativer Ratgeber Beliebteste Favoriten Aktuelle Angebote Vergleichssieger - Direkt weiterlesen! 2 Barristan Selmy. I think Robert and Jaime take this one: either of them could at least hold their own against Selmy for a considerable time - time enough for the other to take Oberyn down, I reckon. There is an illustrative scene in A Game of Thrones when King Robert hurls his breastplate at nearby Ser Barristan, but Selmy calmly dodges. Anyone can nominate a setting in the world of ASOIAF. I'm excited to see which setting gets chosen, I think it's going to have a high likelihood of determining the winner. Achilles(Troy) vs Arthur Dayne, Barristan Selmy and Robert Baratheon Battle Fight takes place near the Tower of Joy. [8] A celebrated hero, he has served in the Kingsguard since a time when these knights were still considered to be the greatest of the Seven Kingdoms. The Red Viper and the Lord of Storm's End Vs. Barristan the Bold. Oberyn is well suited to Robert's type (to a lesser degree than Gregor) and is more likely to draw first blood, resulting in a poisoned Robert, which secures Oberyn the fight. Voting will open after the debate has concluded. Well done. I dothink that Jaime could and would hold Ser Barristan off long enough for Robert to join and kill Barristan with the help of The Kingslayer. added by vici-mercedes. The top of the wall. Robert killed Rhaegar but Barristan is far superior in swordplay. Close or exact matches were combined. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. 7 Loras Tyrell. The sequences would entail Robert beating Oberyn and Jaime either dying to Barristan or stalling him long enough to where the Stag can join the Lion and kill Ol' Selmy. Created by @MeereeneseKnot, The Great Castles of Westeros: An Unofficial Guide by Joe Buckley, The Unofficial Guide to Game of Thrones by Kim Renfro, Try LISTENING to ASOIAF! (As in, nominate yourself for moderator by replying to my top level comment that says Debate Moderator Nominations and so on.). Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. My money there would be on Barristan Selmy. I'd like to think Jaime will be the swift and tricky blade while Robert is the brute force that keeps Selmy and Oberyn on the defensive, allowing effective team work from their different fighting styles to help Team 1 win. * Robert Baratheon de joven se los carga a todos. Once again great matchup. News and discussions relating to George R. R. Martin's "A Song of Ice and Fire" novels, his Westeros-based short stories, the "Game of Thrones" and "House of the Dragon" TV series, and all things ASOIAF - but with particular emphasis on the written series. I'd give the edge to team 2. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. There is no limit to how many times a person can consecutively serve as moderator. In the arena area used for grooms trial by combat. The issue is Viper v. Big Bob. cersei and meryn trant. It's standard gear, and since Widow's Wail really never was his standard in his combat days, I will say no Widow's Wail. Either Oberyn makes a mistake or he finds a spot in Robert's armor and finishes him. Team 2 wins ever so slightly imo, Selmey in his prime would be something else~. Honor Dad. It was written by Dave Hill and narrated by Ian McElhinney as Barristan Selmy. Robert is either more capable of dealing with Barristan than Jaime or less so. The gates of the Red Keep. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. Welche Kriterien es bei dem Bestellen die Anita sport bh extreme control zu beurteilen gilt. Jaime will be difficult to beat though I think Barristan can hold his own at least against him while using up Jaime's stamina. Sin dragones y con todos de una pieza, el top de guerreros de Poniente de CdHyF sera algo as: 1 Arthur Dayne. Settings have to be workable. My money's on Team 1. 15 comments share save hide report 100% Upvoted This thread is archived New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast Sort by best The book Jaime slaughter's book Oberyn. The moderator and champions will be given a week to study their warrior/battle and prepare their opening statements. Ser Barristan Selmy, also known as Barristan the Bold and Arstan Whitebeard, is an anointed knight of House Selmy.